Skip Navigation
InitialsDiceBearhttps://github.com/dicebear/dicebearhttps://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/„Initials” (https://github.com/dicebear/dicebear) by „DiceBear”, licensed under „CC0 1.0” (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/)ST
Posts
9
Comments
91
Joined
2 yr. ago
  • Overwriting canon is fine, actually. TOS never had an issue with it, and PIC S1E10 gave Data a much better send-off by breaking canon from Nemesis and other Soong episodes. Gene Roddenberry's assistant officially decanonized TAS, but better writers still acknowledge it.

    The idea of "canon" in regard to fictional worlds is dubious anyway, especially ones developed across multiple writers and generations. I'm fine with stuffing Pike's comment about women on the bridge into the dustbin of history, and not stressing about what decade the Eugenics Wars happened, and assuming PIC S3 doesn't exist.

  • In the Lucas movies, droids are pretty explicitly portrayed as chattel slaves. They are auctioned off, have separate inferior quarters (Jabba's droid quarters are particularly notable), and are basically treated as beings without agency despite definitely having agency. There's even an explicit visual analogy - Anakin and Shmi have collars that control them and could kill them, and the droids also have (spaceships shaped like) collars that control them and can kill them.

  • The reason he asked about SNW is because SNW might actually not have the problems you're describing. You mentioned two tropes of modern Trek - the galactic danger and Section 31 - but SNW doesn't use those tropes. Did you misread his question?

    As for the advancement of society (optimism vs aspiration) - TOS shows us a Federation that has moved beyond money and greed, sure. But war is still possible; Errand of Mercy established that there had recently been a war with the Klingons, decades before DIS and SNW portrayed it. The death penalty is still a possible punishment for Federation officers (maybe citizens too?) in The Menagerie. McCoy makes bigoted comments toward his ship's first officer regularly. If anything, SNW shows a more advanced society than TOS did. (I can't imagine SNW Pike expressing TOS Pike's opinion about women on the bridge!) Surely it makes sense that SNW's society should resemble TOS's more than TNG's.

    But the bigger sense of advancement across the entire franchise is still here too. A key point in SNW S1E1 is that society has moved beyond partisan struggles and infighting - the ability to explore space and live in the stars is tied directly to this sense of social harmony which we still lack. This was also true in previous eras of Trek, and is exactly why warp travel is the criteria to be contacted by the Federation. SNW shows that these writers get it, and continue to get it.

  • Of the previous Trek movies, we have:

    A deliberately ponderous sci-fi epic

    A submarine story fueled by revenge

    A crew who risks everything to save one friend

    A reunion special with a "save the whales" message front and center

    An ego project with ambition

    A political/spy thriller

    A crossover for the fans

    A zombie movie

    A long episode of TNG

    The second movie again but worse

    A reboot with plot holes

    A misunderstood action flick

    A Fast & Furious movie

    So how is this "not Trek" while all of those are Trek?

  • It can't be explained directly, by itself. They're part of a bigger picture.

    Straight men are attracted to women on the whole - legs, arms, waist, face, chest, back, it's all good. Whatever force it is that makes us attracted to women, it's not something that we chose or decided. We just do.

    Since boobs are a sign of femininity, they're attractive to us on exactly that level! They fit into our idea of what women look like.

  • I like Fossil-SCM, so https://chiselapp.com is good for that. But if you want to stick to Git, Forgejo is the best open-source offering (and Codeberg is the most prominent instance). If you want to tread far off of the beaten path, https://hub.darcs.net might meet your needs.

    We'll all benefit once the forgefed project is done, and Forgejo/Gitea/Gitlab can all interact with each other.

  • I like life imprisonment for heinous people specifically because it seems like the less merciful option. Look at how many mass shooters and terrorists also take their own lives during the act - suicide is one of their objectives. If we can capture them alive and make them live in a small room, eating unexciting food and sleeping on thin mattresses for decades still to come - that's the ultimate rebuke to their ideologies of death. Execution, on the other hand, is giving them what they seek.

  • Law enforcement has been collecting fingerprints for over 100 years now, and the history of using fingerprints for other reasons goes even further back.

    The error here is that we decided to start using an easily obtainable piece of data as a "lock" on our phones and computers. For many reasons, it's better to use a password or PIN.

  • Star Trek Social Club @startrek.website
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Star Trek Adventures 2E is available as PDF now!

    Star Trek Social Club @startrek.website
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Star Trek Adventures 2E FREE quickstart rules are up!

    Programming @beehaw.org
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Does anyone here use Exercism? I've started using it to learn Elixir, and it seems to be good. I'm thinking about having my kids use it as well for Python and JS/TS.

    I'd be interested to hear if anyone's used it for a long time, and if there's any advantages or disadvantages to it. Or if there are other, better code exercise sites I should check out.

    Star Trek Social Club @startrek.website
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Good Enterprise novels?

    I always thought that the idea of Enterprise was intriguing, and that the characters had a lot of potential. I don't think the show lived up to its own possibilities. But that's where books can make up the difference, maybe!

    So, can anyone recommend some Enterprise novels that are worth reading?

    (Especially if they have nothing to do with the "Temporal Cold War" and aren't simple jailbreak stories. The show already has those angles covered.)

    Gaming @beehaw.org
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Fighting game stick recommendations?

    I'm getting back into fighting games! And I don't want to wear out my gamepads or joycons, so can you recommend a good control stick?

    A few criteria:

    • Wireless would be ideal
    • Compatible with PC mainly, but Switch and Playstation would be excellent too.
    • I'm mainly into BlazBlue and Injustice right now, not sure if that would affect my choices.
    Tabletop Gaming @beehaw.org
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Starfinder Second Edition announced!

    More info at https://paizo.com/starfinderplaytest

    According to the document they have up there, SF2E will be 100% compatible with PF2E. That's a huge win for me - I like Starfinder's setting and vibe, and love PF2E's action economy.

    Star Trek Social Club @startrek.website
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    The Lower Decks Campaign Guide is released!

    I'll be giving this a read after work, but if anyone else wants to share their thoughts on the book, go for it!

    Gaming @beehaw.org
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    A taxonomy of Roguelikes

    I've been thinking about a taxonomy of Roguelikes that should help us speak more clearly about this genre - or group of genres - that we love. I'd rather do this than just call things "roguelites", which basically doesn't mean anything. So here we go!

    True Rogues: you're alone in a dangerous, randomly-generated dungeon, moving one turn at a time (except for speed-altering mechanics), with the possibility of permadeath always looming. Less objectively, these games tend to be more dangerous up-front, and require the player to master the mechanics in early levels - while still ramping up the threat for players who survive to later floors. Rogue, Brogue, Nethack, Jupiter Hell, and DCSS all fit here.

    Bandlikes: inspired by Angband. Distinguished from True Rogues by the presence of one or more "towns" - places of safety that allow you to recover or improve outside of danger - with the attendant "town portal" abilities to get you there & back easily. This results, quite deliberately, in a l

    RPG @lemmy.ml
    SteleTrovilo @beehaw.org

    Excellent thread about the OGL by Cory Doctorow

    mamot.fr Cory Doctorow's linkblog (@[email protected])

    Attached: 1 image Last week, Gizmodo's Linda Codega caught a fantastic scoop - a leaked report of #Hasbro's plan to revoke the decades-old #OpenGamingLicense, which subsidiary #WizardsOfTheCoast promulgated as an allegedly #open sandbox for people seeking to extend, remix or improve #DungeonsAndDra...

    Cory Doctorow's linkblog (@pluralistic@mamot.fr)

    He is not a lawyer (and neither am I) but Doctorow knows a great deal about licenses and rights, and I definitely learned some interesting things from this.