It looks like we're getting decent options now? Like the Clicks one is designed in cooperation with a former Blackberry designer. From what I see on Reddit, BB Key2 from 2018 was the last good option in this space, so I understand the excitement.
Both are midrange. If you're basing your desicion on a cause (which seems to be the case as you're posting here) the sustainability aspects of Fairphone (both environmental and social) should make it a clear winner for you. It also has official /e/os/ support (European de-googled Android) if you ever decide to go down that path in the future.
““We either hang together, or we will hang separately.” – George Washington” – Michael Scott