I'm not talking about florets, I'm talking about everyone who isn't Affini. No civilization is permitted to self-govern without Affini interference.

Once the Affini Compact becomes aware of a civilization, their domestication is inevitable. Generally speaking, while there are no civilizations more advanced than the Compact, even such precursor cultures would be unable to resist the Affini indefinitely

When a species accepts the Compact, they tend to have much more of a say in the running of their society afterward — but even these cultures will be altered by domestication, and the Compact will still be there with a firm hand on the wheel afterward, just in case. Species that resist domestication, like Terrans did, don't get much of a say in how things are run — a species that fights back needs much more correction, from the Affini perspective, than one that willingly joins the Compact.

Basically, you're free to self-govern as a vassal of the compact as long as you do what you're told and don't want independence. That's not freedom. That's not political rights. That's abuse. Guess what, black slaves who did what their masters told them were treated better too, but that doesn't mean they had freedom.

I have little experience with HDG, but I'm afraid you have little understanding of what communism and freedom mean, and that's far more important. So far we have not disagreed on the facts of the fiction. We've only disagreed on the facts of political systems and ethics.

I do in fact believe the Affini are entirely benevolent. They are also wrong. They are monsters who mean well.